No, I wouldn't think so.. Odds are it was broken in the process of being bagged when caught and transfered to where ever it was that she was sent. These guy's are pretty much handled like a bunch of worms when being dealt with in the trade. Those guy's just scoop up a bunch at a time and they don't care if they are still trying to cling to something or not. You can find many in the trade that will have even missing toes.. She will be Ok. They manage just fine with this little handicap!!